How do other EU countries’ post-Brexit residence permits compare to Denmark?
After reports this week that Danish authorities plan to deport a British national who failed to apply for post-Brexit residence status on time, we look at how other EU countries have applied residency permit rules following the UK’s withdrawal from the EU.
Phil Russell, a UK national who lives in the western part of Zealand with his Danish partner, submitted an application for a post-Brexit residence permit four days after the December 31st, 2021 deadline.
Russell has since been informed he must leave the country by December 6th but has the right to appeal the decision. He has notified authorities that he intends to appeal and his residence and working rights in Denmark are protected while the appeal is ongoing.
READ ALSO:
- ‘Absurd’: Briton living in Denmark urges authorities to reverse his deportation order
- British citizen faces deportation from Denmark after missing residence card deadline
Under Denmark’s application of the Brexit Withdrawal Agreement, British nationals who moved to Denmark under EU free movement rules before December 31st, 2020 were required to submit an application for new residence status and a new residence document by the end of 2021.
Up to September 30th, Danish authorities have received 290 late applications for post-Brexit continued residency status.
Decisions on some applications made after the deadline are still being processed, meaning it is not clear how many UK nationals have already or could yet lose their residency rights.
The Brexit Withdrawal Agreement’s Article 5 states that the EU and UK must “take all appropriate measures, whether general or particular, to ensure fulfilment of the obligations arising from this Agreement and shall refrain from any measures which could jeopardise the attainment of the objectives of this Agreement.”
One of the stated objectives of the agreement is to protect the rights of citizens to continue living and working in their respective countries after Brexit.
Below, we look at how other countries have continued residence rights for Britons who lived in those countries prior to Brexit.
Sweden
On its website, the Swedish Migration Agency says it “can accept an application for residence status that has come in after” its deadline which, like in Denmark, was December 31st 2021.
“This presupposes that there are reasonable grounds for why you did not apply in time. A review will be done of each individual case,” the agency says.
People with permanent residence permits have the right to continue to stay in Sweden as usual even after the deadline, according to the Migration Agency. Those with temporary residence permits in Sweden may need to apply for a work permit.
The Swedish rules have nevertheless caused some uncertainty for resident Britons.
According to a section on the Migration Agency website, post-Brexit residence status “applies indefinitely”. The certificate which was issued to those who applied before the deadline of December 31st 2021, however, is only valid for five years.
This has left many of those holding the certificate concerned that laws might change to prevent them from renewing their certificate when that period ends.
READ ALSO:
- What problems have Brits in Sweden been facing as a result of Brexit?
- Brit deported from Sweden over Brexit deadline ’put on the plane like a drug dealer’
France
Like Denmark, application for a post-Brexit residence card was required in France. All Brits who were living in France before December 30th 2020 needed to apply for a residency permit known as a carte de séjour.
The original deadline for applications was June 2021, but the French government extended this several times - and also extended the deadline to be in possession of the card - due to high demand and fears that Covid restrictions would prevent people from meeting the original deadline.
Since January 1st 2022 it has been compulsory for all Brits who were living in France before Brexit to have the post-Brexit carte de séjour.
Evidence suggests that France has taken a relaxed approach to the process - only a tiny fraction of applications for residency were refused, most on the grounds of serious criminality. Groups working with Brits in France have reported that local préfectures have been willing to process a small number of applications that were received after the deadline.
Spain
Spanish authorities have been lenient and informative regarding how Brits can guarantee their Withdrawal Agreement rights, but a number of Britons in Spain did not have residency or other official documents and could not prove they were living in Spain before 2021.
According to reports, people in that situation have been told to leave at (sometimes very) short notice and apply for a non-EU residency visa if their residency application is rejected.
However, previous (pre-Brexit) EU residency documents that Britons have are still valid and it's not compulsory to update to Spain’s new non-EU residence card. As such, only people who were not previously registered have run into issues.
Italy
Italy's post-Brexit card isn't mandatory but the British Embassy in Italy advises residents to apply for it to prove their status under the Withdrawal Agreement.
This means you don't need a residency card if you have alternative proof of pre-Brexit residency.
However, while Italian authorities have often accepted other forms of proof, they have also sometimes required the card, causing some level of uncertainty.
READ ALSO: How many of Italy’s British residents have successfully applied for a post-Brexit residency card?
Germany
Residence rights after Brexit were automatically granted to British nationals who lived in Germany prior to the deadline, so they don’t need Germany’s residence card – although it is still recommended.
There have been reports of passport stamping for British residents in Germany, even if they have the residence card.
Overall, Germany has a lenient system, transferring rights automatically and without demanding application for a new card or updated residence status.
READ ALSO: How Brits can prove their post-Brexit rights in Germany – before they get their residence card
Comments
See Also
Phil Russell, a UK national who lives in the western part of Zealand with his Danish partner, submitted an application for a post-Brexit residence permit four days after the December 31st, 2021 deadline.
Russell has since been informed he must leave the country by December 6th but has the right to appeal the decision. He has notified authorities that he intends to appeal and his residence and working rights in Denmark are protected while the appeal is ongoing.
READ ALSO:
- ‘Absurd’: Briton living in Denmark urges authorities to reverse his deportation order
- British citizen faces deportation from Denmark after missing residence card deadline
Under Denmark’s application of the Brexit Withdrawal Agreement, British nationals who moved to Denmark under EU free movement rules before December 31st, 2020 were required to submit an application for new residence status and a new residence document by the end of 2021.
Up to September 30th, Danish authorities have received 290 late applications for post-Brexit continued residency status.
Decisions on some applications made after the deadline are still being processed, meaning it is not clear how many UK nationals have already or could yet lose their residency rights.
The Brexit Withdrawal Agreement’s Article 5 states that the EU and UK must “take all appropriate measures, whether general or particular, to ensure fulfilment of the obligations arising from this Agreement and shall refrain from any measures which could jeopardise the attainment of the objectives of this Agreement.”
One of the stated objectives of the agreement is to protect the rights of citizens to continue living and working in their respective countries after Brexit.
Below, we look at how other countries have continued residence rights for Britons who lived in those countries prior to Brexit.
Sweden
On its website, the Swedish Migration Agency says it “can accept an application for residence status that has come in after” its deadline which, like in Denmark, was December 31st 2021.
“This presupposes that there are reasonable grounds for why you did not apply in time. A review will be done of each individual case,” the agency says.
People with permanent residence permits have the right to continue to stay in Sweden as usual even after the deadline, according to the Migration Agency. Those with temporary residence permits in Sweden may need to apply for a work permit.
The Swedish rules have nevertheless caused some uncertainty for resident Britons.
According to a section on the Migration Agency website, post-Brexit residence status “applies indefinitely”. The certificate which was issued to those who applied before the deadline of December 31st 2021, however, is only valid for five years.
This has left many of those holding the certificate concerned that laws might change to prevent them from renewing their certificate when that period ends.
READ ALSO:
- What problems have Brits in Sweden been facing as a result of Brexit?
- Brit deported from Sweden over Brexit deadline ’put on the plane like a drug dealer’
France
Like Denmark, application for a post-Brexit residence card was required in France. All Brits who were living in France before December 30th 2020 needed to apply for a residency permit known as a carte de séjour.
The original deadline for applications was June 2021, but the French government extended this several times - and also extended the deadline to be in possession of the card - due to high demand and fears that Covid restrictions would prevent people from meeting the original deadline.
Since January 1st 2022 it has been compulsory for all Brits who were living in France before Brexit to have the post-Brexit carte de séjour.
Evidence suggests that France has taken a relaxed approach to the process - only a tiny fraction of applications for residency were refused, most on the grounds of serious criminality. Groups working with Brits in France have reported that local préfectures have been willing to process a small number of applications that were received after the deadline.
Spain
Spanish authorities have been lenient and informative regarding how Brits can guarantee their Withdrawal Agreement rights, but a number of Britons in Spain did not have residency or other official documents and could not prove they were living in Spain before 2021.
According to reports, people in that situation have been told to leave at (sometimes very) short notice and apply for a non-EU residency visa if their residency application is rejected.
However, previous (pre-Brexit) EU residency documents that Britons have are still valid and it's not compulsory to update to Spain’s new non-EU residence card. As such, only people who were not previously registered have run into issues.
Italy
Italy's post-Brexit card isn't mandatory but the British Embassy in Italy advises residents to apply for it to prove their status under the Withdrawal Agreement.
This means you don't need a residency card if you have alternative proof of pre-Brexit residency.
However, while Italian authorities have often accepted other forms of proof, they have also sometimes required the card, causing some level of uncertainty.
READ ALSO: How many of Italy’s British residents have successfully applied for a post-Brexit residency card?
Germany
Residence rights after Brexit were automatically granted to British nationals who lived in Germany prior to the deadline, so they don’t need Germany’s residence card – although it is still recommended.
There have been reports of passport stamping for British residents in Germany, even if they have the residence card.
Overall, Germany has a lenient system, transferring rights automatically and without demanding application for a new card or updated residence status.
READ ALSO: How Brits can prove their post-Brexit rights in Germany – before they get their residence card
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.